The National Top 100 Trial Lawyers
Expertise 2020
Expertise 2016
Avvo Rating
Avvo Clients' Choice Award 2017
Avvo Criminal Defense
Avvo Top Contributor 2015

Broken Tail Light Not a Legal Reason to Stop

Broken Tail Light Not a Legal Reason to Stop

I keep telling you this, and it bears repeating–this is the United States of America. Supposedly, the most free country on earth. Sometimes it’s hard to notice all this “freedom” when the police are stopping cars for equipment violations, when they should be out catching the bad guys.

Our question of the day goes something like this: if your car has a few things wrong with it, a few items in dis-repair, does that give the government the right to pull you over and issue a ticket? Heck No. Well, sort of no. Let me break this down.

The example of the day is broken tail lights. Imagine that your rear brake light is cracked, and when you brake it emits a “white light” thru the cracks. Does this broken tail light, emitting white light, allow an officer to pull you over, just to give you a warning about the faulty equipment?

No. While it’s true that the Florida Statutes do permit an officer to stop a car when the officer believes that the vehicle is not equipped as required by law (Fla. Stat. 316.610(1)), the Florida Supreme Court held in Doctor v. State that cracked tail lights cannot support a vehicle stop unless said lights created a safety hazard. 596 So.2d 442, 446 (Fla. 1992).

Our Supreme Court’s reasoning is sound, as the police cannot have free reign under 316.610 to pull over every car with an equipment malfunction, as this “would permit officers to stop vehicles for such defects as broken radio antenna or a dent in the passenger door of the vehicle.” Hilton v. State, 961 So.2d 284, 290-291 (Fla. 2007).

The bottom line: Sometimes, you may think, “Gee, that was nice of Mr. Police Officer to pull me over and give me a “warning””–but in reality, that officer probably had no right to pull you over in the first place. A warning is really just the officer’s way of saying “I thought you might have drugs or guns, but since you don’t, I won’t charge you with a bogus infraction”. Now you know.

Client Reviews

If you need legal help your in the right place John Guidry is efficient professional and gets the job done. There’s no games or gimmicks. John will always be highly recommended by me . Thank you John for all of your help.

Jovon W.

Straightforward and will go the extra mile for you. If the unfortunate need ever arises, John would always be my first call. Honesty and integrity are the words that come to mind in reference to his impeccable service. Thankful for you, John.

Renee F.

If you need an excellent lawyer I would recommend the Law Firm of John Guidry 100%. He took the time to hear me out and helped me with my case. Thank you so much John.

Edwin M.

Contact Us

  1. 1 Free Consultation
  2. 2 Available 24/7
  3. 3 Over 28 Years of Experience
Fill out the contact form or call us at (407) 423-1117 to schedule your free consultation.