The National Top 100 Trial Lawyers
Expertise 2020
Expertise 2016
Avvo Rating
Avvo Clients' Choice Award 2017
Avvo Criminal Defense
Avvo Top Contributor 2015

Changing Residence Without Permission Leads to VOP

Changing Residence Without Permission Leads to VOP

How hard is it to prove a negative? Urban myth claims that “you can’t prove a negative”. Take the rather cliched statement notion that we can never prove that “God does not exist”–because we can’t prove a negative. This is intellectually lazy nonsense, as there are good arguments both for, and against, a Creator. That being said, the word “God” creates friction between myself and my web optimizer people, as they deem such discussions “difficult to optimize for search engines.” Hum, what do these SEO people do, anyway? Ok, I’ll stop.

Still, it’s easy to prove a negative. Take the following statement: No Ferrari’s exist in John’s garage. Can we prove this negative? Sure. Open my garage door, and bam, there’s no Ferrari (most statements can be transformed into a negative). Speaking of cars, I would like an Italian sports car–of any ilk–even an Alfa Romeo (basically, some of the least expensive Italian cars out there). [So, if you’re really interested as to why you can prove negatives, and I bet none of you are, but just in case, check out Steven D. Hales article “Thinking Tools: You Can Prove a Negative”].

Many violations of probation involve proving a negative. Let’s delve into why probation fails on such issues.

A common probation violation involves changing residence without the permission of probation. Typically, this violation occurs when probation decides to make that dreaded “home visit”. And, that’s just what happened in our case of the day, Allen v. State, 211 So. 3d 55 (Fla. 4th DCA 2017). Allen was found guilty of violating 5 years of probation, and received a 25 year prison sentence upon violating that probation. He violated with a few new charges, and by changing his residence without informing his probation officer. We’re only going to address the change of residence.

As we said, Allen’s probation officer decides to visit his home. Surprise surprise, he’s not there. Yes, you could visit me at home right now, and I’m not there either, I’m at the office slaving over this article. Now, if your probation officer (PO) has an itchy trigger finger, one such visit may be all it takes to end up with a violation, but Allen’s PO decided to visit a second time. “The second time she visited, she was stopped by a locked gate and could see a realtor’s lock on the door.” id. at 7. Hum. Allen was not present for two visits. Probation’s response “he must have moved! I’m violating his ass.” (I made up probation’s response, but I’m sure its fairly accurate)

After the second visit, do we now have a legit violation for changing residence without permission? No. The court held that “the fact that Allen was not present the two times the probation officer visited would not establish that he had moved.” id. Strike One.

What about the realtor’s lock box, does that fact push this into violation territory? Nope. The court noted that a “lock box does not necessarily mean that the renter no longer lives there. It may only have meant that a realtor was showing the house.” id. Strike Two.

So, how do you prove a negative, and show the court that “Allen no longer lives here”? The court hinted that evidence from the owner of the home would be helpful, but I would argue even that that isn’t enough. For example, I had client arrested for failure to register as a sex offender, after the sex offender task force found his registered home to be vacant. We didn’t challenge that the home was vacant, and even the owner (out of state investor) testified that my client was no longer living in the home. Still, the case was dismissed. Why? The State couldn’t refute my client’s testimony that he continued to live in a back shed of the house. As such, his address was still valid. An empty home and home owner testimony couldn’t establish that my client had moved. Case dismissed.

Even though the appellate court overturned Allen’s conviction for changing residence without permission, the court upheld other aspects of his violation, so he’s stuck with 25 years in prison.

Sometimes, people don’t realize how serious violations of probation are. On five years of probation, how bad could a VOP sentence really be? In Allen’s case, the answer was two and a half decades behind bars. Yikes.

Client Reviews

If you need legal help your in the right place John Guidry is efficient professional and gets the job done. There’s no games or gimmicks. John will always be highly recommended by me . Thank you John for all of...

Jovon W.

Straightforward and will go the extra mile for you. If the unfortunate need ever arises, John would always be my first call. Honesty and integrity are the words that come to mind in reference to his impeccable...

Renee F.

If you need an excellent lawyer I would recommend the Law Firm of John Guidry 100%. He took the time to hear me out and helped me with my case. Thank you so much John.

Edwin M.

Thank you once again John for helping out with Cameron. I truly appreciate your generosity on his last case and hoping and praying that will be the end of his shenanigans. You are the best! Just a small token...

Teresa and Cameron

I would highly recommend this firm! Living out of state I was at ease knowing that Mr. John was taking care of it all! He kept me in the loop of all parties involved and handled it very professionally! I’m very...

Robbin F.

I have had the privilege of having John Guidry as my lawyer. By far the most Professional and caring Lawyer I have ever had help me with resolving any of my legal concerns. I assure you no one will fight harder...

Paul M.

Attorney Guidry is THE REAL DEAL. His communication is impeccable and the results are undeniable. If ever I was not able to get a hold of him, he contacted me in a timely manner. I would recommended him on any...

Nikko S.

Live in Illinois, and hired John to remove a file for me in Florida and had an amazing experience. Mr Guidry and all of his office staff was kind and professional and held my hand the whole way. I highly...

Nick S.

Home Client Reviews Client Reviews Testimonial of a Mother Who Hired Us to Help With Her Son’s Battery CaseTestimonial of a Mother Who Hired Us to Help With Her Son’s Battery Case DUI Client Testimonial DUI...

Natalie and Donata Damond

John really took ownership of my case and got it resolved very quickly. He kept me up to date with everything and he himself spoke to me and didn’t send an assistant to call like other people. I really...

Luis C.

John, I can’t begin to thank you for all that you’ve done for Andrew. You’ve given me a peace of mind, and that is a priceless gift to a mom! Thank you for your professionalism, patience, and for being such an...

Justine Petterson (Andrew Boris’ mom)

Dear John, Mary Lou and I wanted to end the year with a note of appreciation to you, Chelsey and your staff. We are grateful for the efforts you have made on behalf of our son, Chad, and we remain hopeful yet...

Joe Ramsay (and Mary Lou)

Excellent service was able to hep me with my case so easily and gave me the best outcome and wonderful and really professional. Quick to respond

Daniel V.

He will always contact you directly to answer any questions in your case. Excellent customer support from his staff. Case by case they offer prompt answers and good results.

Alexa R.

Contact Us

  1. 1 Free Consultation
  2. 2 Available 24/7
  3. 3 Over 28 Years of Experience
Fill out the contact form or call us at (407) 423-1117 to schedule your free consultation.